Enterprise AI Analysis
Revolutionizing Peer Feedback: The Strategic Value of GenAI
This study explores students' perceptions and use of Generative AI (GenAI) during peer feedback activities in a master's course. Fifty-four graduate students received instruction on ethical GenAI use, provided peer feedback, revised essays, and completed a questionnaire. Results indicate that just over half of students chose not to use GenAI, primarily due to a belief in greater learning from independent work. Those who did use GenAI found it moderately helpful for improving both high-level and low-level feedback aspects. GenAI users provided more suggestions for high-level issues and less mitigating praise for low-level issues. These findings offer insights for designing GenAI tools to enhance peer feedback practices.
The integration of Generative AI (GenAI) into learning and development processes holds significant implications for enterprise training programs and professional skill enhancement. This research demonstrates how GenAI can serve as a valuable tool for feedback provision, potentially improving the efficiency and quality of peer-to-peer learning within organizations. Enterprises can leverage GenAI to provide scalable, timely, and tailored feedback, addressing challenges like heavy workloads and time constraints for trainers. Understanding student perceptions – particularly the preference for independent learning and concerns about policy compliance – is crucial for successful enterprise adoption. By designing structured training and clear ethical guidelines, companies can maximize GenAI's benefits in fostering higher-order skills and balancing cognitive and socio-emotional aspects of feedback, ultimately leading to more effective workforce development.
Quantifiable Enterprise Impact
GenAI can significantly enhance learning and development within your organization.
0%
Learning Efficiency Increase
0%
Instructor Workload Reduction
0%
Feedback Quality Improvement
Deep Analysis & Enterprise Applications
Select a topic to dive deeper, then explore the specific findings from the research, rebuilt as interactive, enterprise-focused modules.
GenAI Adoption & Perceptions
Impact on Feedback Quality
Implementation Challenges
44%
of students utilized GenAI for peer feedback provision. Many preferred independent learning, but those who used it found it moderately helpful.
Student GenAI Utilization Process
Received GenAI Instruction
→
Wrote Argumentative Essay
→
Provided Peer Feedback (Optional GenAI Use)
→
Revised Essay
→
Completed GenAI Perception Survey
| Feature | GenAI Users (Trial Group) | Non-GenAI Users (Control Group) |
|---|---|---|
| High-Level Suggestions |
|
|
| Mitigating Praise (Low-Level) |
|
|
| Identification & Explanation (All Levels) |
|
|
| Grammar & Spelling Check |
|
|
Addressing Enterprise Adoption Hurdles
The study highlights that students often prefer independent learning and express uncertainty about using GenAI in compliance with university policies. For enterprises, this translates to the need for robust, clear AI governance policies and structured training programs. Emphasize GenAI as a scaffold to enhance, not replace, learning. Focus on balancing cognitive and socio-emotional elements to foster trust and effective integration.
Estimate Your Enterprise AI ROI
Understand the potential time and cost savings from integrating AI-powered feedback into your internal training and development programs.
Estimated Annual Savings
$0
Annual Hours Reclaimed
0
Your Enterprise AI Feedback Roadmap
A phased approach to integrating AI for enhanced peer feedback.
Phase 1: Pilot & Policy Development
Conduct a small-scale pilot program with clear objectives. Develop and disseminate clear internal policies for ethical and effective GenAI use, addressing data privacy and responsible AI practices.
Phase 2: Structured Training & Integration
Implement comprehensive training for employees on leveraging GenAI as a feedback scaffold, not a replacement. Integrate GenAI tools with existing learning management systems.
Phase 3: Monitor, Evaluate & Scale
Continuously monitor feedback quality and employee perceptions. Evaluate impact on learning outcomes and workload. Refine policies and training based on feedback, then scale across relevant departments.
Phase 4: Foster Hybrid Intelligence
Encourage a 'human-AI collaboration' model, where GenAI augments human insights. Promote critical reflection on AI outputs and continuous improvement of GenAI literacy across the organization.
Ready to Transform Your Learning & Development with AI?
Book a strategic consultation to tailor an AI feedback solution to your enterprise needs.
Ready to Get Started?
Book Your Free Consultation.
Let's Discuss Your AI Strategy!
Lets Discuss Your Needs
Select a Date
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat